Hi,
My post this week is about a very controversial topic. I am here with you to question, should bullying be a crime? I definitely think that this topic needs to be talked about much more than what it is, so I am addressing it now.
What is bullying? Bullying is a child's way of saying
you are different. Bullying is a teenager's way of making themselves seem
better than others. Bullying is an adult's way of
getting what they want, it is
manipulation. Bullying, in all stages of life, is a way to hurt someone.
Bullying is wrong. Bullying is harmful. Bullying
hurts, no matter how unsubstantial the incident is. So then why is bullying not yet a crime?
Really, shouldn't bullying be a crime? A crime is harm done to a person, property, or to self. Isn`t bullying harmful to another person? Of course it is. But there is more to bullying than the obvious statements.
Yes, we all know the tragic stories, "
11 Year old boy commits suicide after being bullied for too long", "
17 year old girl's family grieves after a death occurs due to bullying", among others. But what about the stories that we do not hear? The ones that seem so insignificant that it is hard to decide whether they actually
were bullying incidents, or just harsh words? Should those be considered a crime as well?
Of course, if only the tragic stories occurred, the answer to my question would not be a difficult one to find. The answer would be
yes, bullying is a crime, somebody
died,
of course it is a crime. But with these small incidents, it is hard to decide. How do you expel almost every child in any school? How do you send almost every adult into jail? How would it be possible?
If bullying
was a crime, what would our world be like? Really, how do you catch it before it transforms into something too big? When a child is bullied, it starts out small, like being called a name. From here, it can grow in many different directions. The bullying could turn physical, which is more noticeable than verbal bullying. These are the incidents that are usually caught, because it is easier to see a big violent fight than a small encounter at lunchtime. Verbal and emotional bullying is much harder to see. How do you see somebody being tormented by a bully verbally and emotionally? That is why these cases of bullying usually go unnoticed. So if bullying was a crime, how would we be able to convict people, if we don`t even know that the bullying is happening? How much of a difference would it make?
Also, would the punishments be the same for every case? What would the difference be between, say, a case ending in an accidental death, than a case ending in a suicide? Bullying can result in actions and events that
are crimes, and are dealt with and treated as such.
People today are much more aware of bullying than they were, say, 20 years ago. There are events dedicated to making people aware of bullying that happens and how to stop it, like Pink Shirt Day, and there are movies showing people what bullying can do, like Cyberbully (2011) and Bully (2011).
To some extent, bullying already is a crime, due to events that happen as consequence of the actual bullying. As many of incidents are already dealt with and treated as crimes because of what occurs in them (assault, murder, accidental murder, suicide), and many people are already aware of the dangers of bullying, and stop bullying if they see it, I would find a law to not have much effect.
As for the smaller incidents, society needs to be able to identify them and deal with the situations now, as supposed to when they get out of hand. If we do not deal with the incidents, they can get worse and turn into a crime. But if we are able to stop them before they reach that stage, they should not be a threat anymore.
I think that because major bullying incidents are already treated like crimes, and because people are already so aware of bullying, that bullying should not be a crime. With all the awareness about bullying and knowledge of how to prevent bullying, I think that a law would not help out as much as showing people what kinds of things bullying can do. I don`t know that bullying will ever be gone, but I do know that it can and will get better.
Sources:
http://ca.news.yahoo.com/blogs/canada-politics/bullying-crime-225007123.html
http://www.fortmcmurraytoday.com/ArticleDisplay.aspx?e=3487269
http://www.theprovince.com/life/Bullying+should+crime+Canadians+poll/6229221/story.html